Sometimes, people get confused when considering whether to make an Advance Care Directive (ACD) or a Power of Attorney (POA). Both documents are equally important to have in place. First, we need to understand the effect of each document and the differences between them to ensure that the documents are valid. 

1. What is a Power of Attorney?

A Power of Attorney is a legal document that a person called the Donor or Principal makes to appoint another person (called the 'Attorney') to manage their affairs and act on their behalf. For example, an Attorney may be able to sign a lease, collect debts or determine what medical treatment the Principal will receive.

2. Types of Powers of Attorney

 There are 2 main types of Powers of Attorney:

  1. General Power of Attorney: appoints someone to act in relation to another person's financial and legal affairs for a limited time. It is automatically cancelled if your capacity (or decision-making ability) becomes impaired. 
  2. Enduring Power of Attorney: appoints someone to act in relation to another person's financial, personal and medical affairs and will continue to operate should you have impaired capacity. 

'Capacity' essentially means that you are an adult and you know and understand what you are doing.

In some states in Australia, a person can appoint another person to act in relation to their medical and personal matters in a Power of attorney document. In other states, a person must appoint an Enduring Guardian to look after their medical and personal matters. 

The laws relating to Powers of Attorney vary between states and have recently undergone a national review. Despite popular thought, no intention has been shown to make national uniform Power of Attorney laws. 

3. What is an ACD?

An Advance Care Directive sets out your specific wishes with regard to medical treatment should you suffer an incurable illness and become unable to communicate your wishes for such treatment. It does not appoint anyone to make your decisions (although in some states and territories, such as the Northern Territory, you must appoint an Enduring Attorney in an ACD). Many people have an ACD in place as they want to 'die with dignity.' It's a very personal document and choice and sets out exactly how you want to be treated at the end of your life. An Advance Care Directive can be called different named in different states. For example, in the Northern Territory, an ACD is known as an Advanced Personal Plan.

4. Difference between the two

A Power of Attorney appoints someone else to make decisions on your behalf, whereas an ACD sets out your wishes directly to your medical treatment providers should you be unable to communicate those wishes for medical treatment are.

In some states and territories (such as the Northern Territory), you must appoint an Enduring Attorney in an Advance Care Directive, or Advance Personal Plan. in some states, the previous Enduring Power of Enduring has been replaced by an Advance Care Directive. 

If you are incapacitated in the future and your medical treatment providers have a choice between a Power of Attorney document and an Advance Care Directive, then any wishes set out in the ACD will take precedence over any decisions made by an Attorney under an Enduring Power of Attorney.  This is because an ACD is your document that specifically sets out your wishes and what treatment you would like to receive at this time. You have made these decisions ahead of time and have let your medical providers know. If your medical providers have reason to believe that you have changed your mind about the treatment since the ACD was made, they have the power to override the ACD. 

If you are over 18 years of age and have capacity, you should ensure that you have both an Enduring Power of Attorney and ACD in place. Although it's not enjoyable to think about times in the future such as these, it's important to let your loved ones and others that will be responsible for your care know how you would like to be treated at this time. It's also important that you have appointed someone that you trust to manage your other important matters, such as your financial and legal affairs, under an Enduring Power of Attorney. Both documents are equally important in planning for your future.  




This article contains information of a general nature only and is not specific to your circumstances. This is not legal advice and should not be relied upon without independent legal or financial advice, specific to your circumstances. 

Comment